Reading in Public No. 13
How I decide to DNF a book
Earlier this month, I shared why I enjoy reading books I don’t love. I almost always press through a book, because I find so much value in reading outside my typical taste, genre, preferences, and comfort zone. But, as I shared then, I’m still a proponent of the DNF (did not finish). Life is short and there are so many books to read! So while I don’t frequently DNF, today I’m sharing some of the reasons I might put a book aside, because I get asked this question a lot!
Reading in Public No. 12
In last week’s In Summation newsletter, I shared that while creating my Paperback Summer Reading Guide, I realized that I am quite good at selecting books to read that I know I’m going to like. I also realized that I don’t need or even want to exclusively read books I love. I read for many reasons—yes, a big one is finding books that will I adore, books…
Reasons I might DNF a book:
The number one reason I stop reading is if my reading is getting bogged down by it. If I’m not reading at all because I don’t want to pick up my current read, I put it aside. Momentum is really important in my reading life. While I’m fine with taking a break from reading and feel comfortable just riding out a reading slump, I don’t like to get stuck behind a book. This was the reason I DNF’d The Luminaries (ahem…twice) before finally starting again, finishing it, and adoring it this year!
If I’m not in the right mood for a book and I can tell that while I’m reading (which isn’t always the case), I’ll stop. I want to be a generous reader and reviewer, so if something’s not working for me because of my own headspace, I put it down. I did this earlier this year with Lone Women, and now I’m feeling a craving to pick it back up again.
I’m often reading for a work project like finding contemporary pairings for a Novel Pairings episode or selecting books for the PSRG. If I’m reading for a specific purpose and the book I’m in the middle of doesn’t fit, I might stop reading until I have time to come back for it and enjoy it for what it is. A few times I’ve found myself being critical of a book because it wasn’t what I was looking for, and that doesn’t feel fair. I’m so glad I stopped reading Nobody is Ever Missing when I knew it wouldn’t work for the PSRG, because when I returned to it later, I really enjoyed it!
A harsh tone is often something I struggle to get past as a reader. This one is difficult to articulate because I’m not necessarily sure what makes a book feel harsh to me, but I know it when I see it. I can deal with books that are violent, dark, devastating, blunt, or snarky—but abrasive writing rarely works for me. Unless I can easily articulate a reason for creating that harsh and abrasive feeling in a reader, I might put down a book that over relies on this tactic. I have seen rave reviews about House of Cotton and I think it will probably work for many readers, but, to me, it was too harsh to continue on.
Finally, I strongly dislike feeling manipulated as a reader. I really don’t enjoy feeling like an author is withholding information to keep me turning the pages and not giving me another reason to keep going. If I only care about finding out what happened and not how the author gets us there in terms of writing, structure, or character development, I implement the “skim to finish” (STF anyone?). I’ve read many a thriller with this method…
How often do you DNF books? What makes you put a book down and when do you push through?
Reading in Public deep dives are supported by paid subscribers to the FictionMatters Newsletter. If you enjoyed today’s topic, please consider forwarding it to a friend, buying me a coffee, or becoming a paid subscriber. Thanks for your support!
For questions, comments, or suggestions, please don’t hesitate to reach out by emailing fictionmattersbooks@gmail.com or responding directly to this newsletter. I love hearing from you!
This email may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through the links above, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.
-Sara
I almost never DNF. But the reason I do is usually utter ambivalence. I'm happy to read books that I have quibbles with - minor or major - but if I just don't care, and I'm not learning anything or reading it to discuss, I'll put it down.
I definitely DNF if a book isn't working for me for a variety of reasons. I am a firm believer in life being too short to stay with something that isn't working for me. I do read books I don't necessarily like, though. I need to find them compelling in some way to keep reading. However, what I really came here to say is that I definitely skim-to-finish if it is a mystery, thriller or romance that isn't working for me for some reason, but I want to know what happens. I love that term.