FictionMatters

FictionMatters

Share this post

FictionMatters
FictionMatters
Reading in Public No. 6

Reading in Public No. 6

The books that made us English Majors--and the ones that kept us away

Sara Hildreth's avatar
Sara Hildreth
Apr 07, 2023
∙ Paid
11

Share this post

FictionMatters
FictionMatters
Reading in Public No. 6
Share

I always enjoy hearing other book lovers talk about the books that made them readers. Those stories often involve memories of reading under the covers with a flashlight, a character who made them feel seen for the first time, or writing that completely transported out of their humdrum lives into a far-off magical world. Of course, I have those books too. Ella Enchanted was magical, funny, imaginative, and taught me the importance of not always following the rules. Sharon Creech’s books broke my heart and made me fall in love with expansive writers who create expansive webs with their book characters. Tuck Everlasting haunts me to this day.

But the books that made me want to be an English major are different. They’re the ones that made me fall in love with thinking, talking, and writing about books. They’re the books that made me want to dig a little deeper and read between the lines and the ones that generated passionate responses in me. Some of these books inspired me to want to study English because I hated the way my English teacher explained them. I thought my own interpretations were better and I wanted to prove it 😂

Today I’m sharing three books that inspired this type of reading for me. I’m also sharing the (pretty epic) list of books that made you want or not want to be an English major—as gathered on Instagram. It was pretty fun to see such strong reactions to the books you studied in school. In ways both good and bad, these books have stuck with you!

This is the first paid post in my Reading in Public series. The majority of these newsletters will continue to be free for all subscribers, but every so often a post will be for paid subscribers only. In addition to these posts, paying subscribers get my monthly Ranked Reading Recap podcast and monthly In Summation newsletters. Upgrading also gives you access to the FictionMatters Newsletter archives in perpetuity. Right now, you can start a free week-long trial today to see if becoming a paid subscriber is right for you!

FictionMatters Newsletter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Sara Hildreth
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share